Hi Aymeric, I'm taking the liberty of opening a separate topic, as the new auction system is not a bug. I really think it's a shame about this change.
The auctions are a really exciting part of your game. And sorry to point it out, but not everything is exciting. The very idea and principle of auctions still has that appeal of stress, struggle, waiting, monitoring, etc. With this new system, you're killing the game.
With this new system, you're killing everything that makes it interesting.

I think that sellers will lose out too. In some cases, it only takes 1 or 2 bids to get the player, because it won't follow as much.

As with any idea or change, I can already imagine people thinking differently. But I think this change is a real, real shame. And I hope that those who think like me will come forward and that you'll be able to reverse your decision.

All the best,
Rull

Now you just have to think about it a bit, before a player who is perfect between 2-3m, all you have to do is make an offer at 2.1m and no one will go for it because otherwise the bid step is too high. It's just going to help the clever ones or the guys who buy and sell to buy cheap.
Personally, I'm also quite surprised by this change and I'm not in favour of it.

I think it's true that you can think and win, and the smartest, fastest, etc. will do very well. I'm not worried about the pros of buying and selling and auctions.

I just think it kills the thrill of the game and this game didn't need that.
Thanks for your comment

Rull43: Je trouve effectivement qu'on peut réfléchir et y gagner, les plus malins, rapides, etc s'en sortiront tres tres bien. Je ne m'inquiète pas pour les pros de l'achat-vente et des enchères.

Je trouve juste que cela tue un côté palpitant du jeu et ce jeu n'avait pas besoin de cela.
Merci pour ton commentaire

I don't see what's so exciting when resale becomes difficult, when players leave for less than 10m at auction, when we know very well that they're not worth it, or when the sale of players trained over several seasons yields nothing.
I'm waiting to see what new thing you're referring to.

I agree with Rull.
I also fear the loss of interest in the auction's primary mechanism, which is to keep the buyer on his toes until the end of the auction and to sniff out bids that are more difficult to sniff out on the list. In this logic, the auction would 'boil down' (I stress the inverted commas) to placing the last bid economically in line with the player's value.

I can understand the aim of protecting the seller's interests more, but using auctions to sell also means accepting the risk of seeing your player leave at a lower price than you would have rationally obtained by placing him on the list.

This is just my personal opinion on the measure. A pleasant evening to all VFians 😉👍

It does not protect, I give you an example a player ng60 25 years, was selling at about 1-1.5m before. Today, if you bid 800k, the next bid will be around 1.7m. Nobody is going to bid 1.7m and so the person who bids 800k will win compared to before and the seller loses because he would have sold more before.

Lulo: Ça protège pas, je te donne un exemple un joueur ng60 a 25ans, se vendait à environ 1-1.5m avant. Aujourd’hui si tu mets une enchère 800k la suivante sera de 1.7m environ . Personne ne va mettre 1.7m et donc celui qui aura mis 800k sera gagnant par rapport à avant et le vendeur perd car il aurait vendu plus avant.

Absolutely, I can't see where the seller will win, unless the bidder isn't paying attention.

What I also find a shame is that I don't remember anyone complaining about the auctions or asking for changes, when for the last 10 months there have been dozens and dozens of proposals, some of them very pertinent. OK, so it's not our game, but it's a shame we don't make the necessary changes or come up with the ideas that people are in favour of, rather than changing something that everyone likes.

It's frustrating and a shame.

I'm going to try to find a compromise by making the increase less violent.

aymeric45: Je vais essayer de trouver un compromis en rendant l'augmentation du pallier moins violente.

Sinn, what about text mode comments? There have been requests for months!

aymeric45: Je vais essayer de trouver un compromis en rendant l'augmentation du pallier moins violente.

Thank you 👍

aymeric45: Je vais essayer de trouver un compromis en rendant l'augmentation du pallier moins violente.

Why not double up to a certain point?

Like the first bid +100k, then 200k and the third 400k, up to a level that you can estimate.

Have a nice day

Sun's: Pourquoi ne pas doubler jusqu'à certain cap ?

Genre première enchère +100k suivante 200k la troisième 400k jusqu'à un palier que estimeras bien

Bonne journée

1.6 you go to 3.2. That's exactly what we're criticising in your example. You lose almost 10 bids.
From 4.4 to 8.8. Doubling is huge.

Rull43: 1,6 tu passes à 3,2. C'est exactement ce qu'on critique ds ton exemple. On perd près de 10 enchères.
De 4,4 à 8,8. C'est énorme de doubler.

Yep, hence my first sentence ... Anyway

"Up to a certain point

Have a nice day

aymeric45: Je vais essayer de trouver un compromis en rendant l'augmentation du pallier moins violente.

Hi Aymeric, if you've changed something, we can't see the difference. let's say it's tiny.
It's just that I don't think it's an evolution that improves the game. Let's say the auctions were sometimes very exciting, very dense... this seriously kills that aspect. You go from 15 auctions to 5 or from 5 to 1. It's less exciting.
Apparently I got a few thumbs up on this topic, I wasn't the only one to think so.
Anyway, we'll get used to it. Thanks for reading and replying, that was a victory in itself :)

I want to say, we have to give free shirts to those who are here you're going to ask the address all that. You can also give away free stuff and then hair and toque there too like a GTA video game, it was a bit about toys. We can increase salaries like FC 25 what so you do what I said and then also give jerseys to people too because we can't come and pay for jerseys also balls here alone OK tell you what I said like FC 20 what even normally she would like to do as a video game even I'm moving a bit talk about people alone give me that he meant people, they don't wait but that's not my problem but for me we'd like to give ball jerseys for free so you're told it's not paying to pay to pay to pay to pay and it worked it didn't work also people who don't understand what was said in French you also translate it's true that it's spoken in German but it's true that it's in German he knows how to speak German but there I'm more stupid in French than German. People who don't understand too, I'll tell you that the toys there play that there, football games manager when plays that there the most creative of the shirts that go here there the shirts there I said, we must have our own buses, we can buy, I said we can buy our cars, I video what, we can have our houses all alone there to put her all play there more upstairs it's downstairs where she there play there, tu crois que moi me suis top 10 passé c'est vrai que des jeux si t'es pas bon mais ça vous faites ça comme un jeu comme jeu vidéo vous croyez dit chacun peut avoir sa maison ça va tu es tout seul et puis tout seul quoi dans les gens qui pas mes propos moi c'est pas mon problème, mais là y a parfois vous donner des balles je voulais demander à vous êtes dans quel pays vous êtes dans quelle adresse là vous envoyez les maillots là-bas vous me chacun choisis son maillot qui veut mais c'est pas moi-même veut parler à lui, même lui mec que lui ça

Merry Christmas to everyone, OK they've given you all 2 million no OK me too they've given me millions millions I don't know like that but but it's good but it's good it's good it's good it's good but who do I like who do they have to give emails, they've given free stuff like jerseys shoes like they're going to everything here and give it to me for free and then your address and then they send it to us in address everything that has to do a link for everyone. The option wants me like to pass all this. There we must send the same him, he must develop the he gave jerseys every month what free stuff free what if the shop you free, he can give less PSG jerseys. I don't like the fact that it will be more developed, okay, you can already see that they're going to come here, it will be more developed.

That's right.

Kamoulox!

You don't speak French any more than you speak German. I speak more French than German, German's not my country, so I didn't come to speak German for you. You want my position, no, yes, answer, that's it, I've got news for everyone.

Koneismail790@gmail.com: Tu n’as plus parler le français que l’allemand. Moi c’est plus parler français que l’allemand l’allemand c’est pas mon pays donc y a pas venu parler l’allemand pour vous vous voulez ma position non oui répondez c’est fini j’ai un nouvel à tout le monde.

Take it easy my friend 😁😁😁
It's the newbie syndrome on vf excuse it

OMstar83: Tout à fait.

🤣🤣🤣