Jom Smims |
1h agoHello everyone,
I have a modest proposal to put to you: to add an ELO ranking for clubs on VirtuaFoot, alongside the league tables and honours lists.
For those unfamiliar with ELO rankings, each club is assigned a rating that changes after every match is recorded. Beating a higher-ranked opponent yields more points than beating a lower-ranked one. Conversely, a defeat against a lower-ranked club costs more points than a defeat against a favourite. Even a draw can earn the underdog points.
This would allow us to:
Compare clubs across different leagues. On VF, you can choose your league and take part in various cup competitions. A common rating would provide a benchmark for comparing, for example, a league leader dominating their division with a mid-table club that regularly faces highly-ranked opponents.
Give greater credit to impressive performances. A small club that holds a favourite to a draw in a cup competition could earn Elo points even if it is subsequently knocked out. Conversely, a string of victories against significantly lower-ranked opponents would do little to boost the rating. The ranking would therefore place greater emphasis on the quality of results than on the mere number of wins.
Track your club’s progress. An Elo curve and a breakdown of points gained or lost after each match would allow you to see whether results are improving following a tactical change or a squad overhaul. This would be a motivating goal even when you’re not in contention for the title or promotion.
Provide context before matches. Displaying both ratings on the match page would make it easy to spot a closely-fought contest or gauge the scale of an upset.
Find opponents more easily. A filter by Elo bracket, for example, would help in finding a evenly matched friendly, a stronger opponent to test tactics against, or participants of a similar standard.
Provide new topics for the community. The forum or discussions could highlight the season’s most impressive progress stories, cup upsets or clashes between clubs close to each other in the table. This would also give visibility to clubs that are improving without having yet won any trophies.
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Galywat |
58 min agoHi,
Even though the current ranking system isn’t strictly speaking an ELO system, we’ve got something quite similar at the moment (plus bonus points for cups).
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
RMP-Val |
58 min agoHello,
That’s more or less how the VF index works at the moment.
Playing against big clubs earns you more points and boosts your VF index as well. So, unsurprisingly, the biggest clubs are at the top of this ranking. Especially as it’s dynamic, since it only takes the last three seasons into account.
If we switch the ranking system to Elo, we’ll then need to review the club tier system for unlocking facilities.
Adding an Elo system on top of the current ranking system would be redundant.
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message