Galywat |
43h agoHello,
As has been mentioned quite a few times over the last few weeks, it’s currently very difficult to create an imbalance. We’re seeing a proliferation of 3-4-3 formations with this type of structure (or sometimes a DFC in place of the DLG):

As a result, we often see this sort of stat in matches:

The central channel is completely deserted, and for good reason: previously it was possible to attack down the centre, but that’s no longer possible today against an active opponent, however good they may be, because there simply isn’t enough time and the defence easily gains the upper hand, especially down the centre – I’ll come back to that later. (Nowadays, this is attempted in the overwhelming majority of cases at kick-off, at half-time or during various substitutions). This is a major concern, firstly because it restricts tactical options, but also because two styles of play are becoming very, very problematic: short passing and creative play, which naturally draw our moves down the middle even when we don’t want to attack there (provided, of course, that the opposition are doing their job properly). Obviously, the best – and simplest – solution would be to revert to fixed 4-minute set-piece intervals. This has been said time and again, but apparently it’s not an option. I therefore propose a series of measures to restore a little tactical flexibility; I believe they are all important, though one is more innovative than the others.
1/ Review the distribution of the GAC: a key point is this – broadly speaking, at present, players contribute along a line, in the centre or on the wings depending on their side. Normally, a centre-back contributes 70 per cent in the centre and 15 per cent on the wings. That’s fine, but the goalkeeper does the same thing: from a gameplay perspective, it’s the same as a DFC on ‘normal’ individual marking. For me, this is a problem because he covers the centre too much. I think an exception is needed so that at least 33 per cent of his defensive contribution covers each side, or at a push 20/40/20. Is this possible? Undoubtedly, but I imagine it would require some adjustments.
2/ In my view, it’s becoming important to programme position changes: the idea is to make use of the selectors that appeared a few weeks ago during matches – you can now change a player’s position via the tactics tab for players you’re about to bring on, just before a substitution. I think this should be extended to all players on the pitch, and confirmed in the same way as a new set of instructions, so that it takes effect with the next stats update (currently every 30 seconds, barring exceptional circumstances). In any case, being able to change several at once without necessarily having to click on a player’s position page – but with the changes only taking effect at the same time as the instructions – would be brilliant.
3/ In the example above, it’s glaringly obvious: both teams have a wide-open space down the middle that they can’t exploit; it’s incredibly frustrating, and defending with three at the back is more than enough, as there’s no need to cover areas where the opposition isn’t attacking. Switching to a back four if the teams are evenly matched is pointless in this context (especially with the goalkeeper acting as a fourth defender). We need to allow a bit more leeway for tactical adjustments, making it possible to capitalise on the opponent’s weaknesses, whilst at the same time ensuring that doing so comes at a cost. So here’s a slightly more original proposal:
--> Create a ‘Coach’s Intensive Tactical Adjustment’ (apologies for the term – there’s no doubt a better one out there; I’m not very good at this sort of thing :p).
This would consist of a time slot available during the match (2 x 18 minutes per half) during which a manager could activate a stats bonus on one side: this bonus would be allocated 100 per cent to attack (on a single side). This bonus could be equivalent to 10 per cent of the total ratings of every player in the team.
The bonus would be activated for a minimum of 6 minutes, with no option to withdraw it unless there is an opposition substitution, an injury or a red card. During these 6 minutes, the player who triggered the bonus would not be able to make any player substitutions. In the event of an opposition substitution, a red card or an injury, the bonus would be returned to the player.
Typically, in the example above, one of the two teams could have pressed down the centre, with around 90–95 bonus points for attacking down the centre (there was little or no style involved).
A few important points:
- The downside would be a 50 per cent increase in physical depletion whilst the bonus is active for players on the team that triggered the bonus.
- Each player could continue to vary their tactical instructions during this period.
- The bonus would therefore naturally and slightly decrease over time (decrease in fitness → lower rating → lower bonus)
- No substitutions are permitted for the player who triggered the bonus
- The opposing team can certainly activate a bonus at the same time as their opponent
- No additional XP
- If there are fewer than 6 minutes remaining ==> it can still be used, but only for the time remaining, no more.
==> The main advantages would be to restore unpredictability to the course of the match and to force everyone to anticipate their team’s moves to avoid leaving areas exposed. It could be used to mount a comeback or force a decisive moment. It also requires players to be in good physical shape to avoid a significant drop in stamina that could hamper them for the rest of the match or affect their performance management. It would mean not neglecting the centre, defending more often with four at the back than with three, would lend credibility to a two-man attack, and would restore the usefulness of the PC and Creative Play styles, without undoing the latest developments in the MDM.
It would no doubt require a period of adjustment to the percentages and durations to achieve a balanced system. In my view, the bonus should be based solely on player ratings, to avoid over-empowering certain styles such as Offside Trap. I see it as a targeted attacking bonus, as that is what the game desperately needs right now.
Have a good evening
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Radio |
39h agoD'accord avec le constat.
Toujours pas fan du principe de "jeton" ou "boost" (ici recyclés).
Galywat |
31h agoYes, I understand, even though it’s still a bit different from the token in the sense that there’s a downside—it’s limited to the attack and to a specific time frame, cannot be instantly countered by the opponent via a player substitution (which is what happens today), and is decoupled from the instructions.
The problem is that, at present, it’s far too ‘easy’ to model the defence on the attack, with few players; if we don’t want to revert to fixed tactics, we’ll inevitably have to resort to this sort of workaround. The transition time is far too costly to fundamentally change attacking tactics (shifting focus to the wings or vice versa)
I remain convinced, however, that the simplest solution is still a return to fixed 4-minute tactics, with a stat penalty for each change of tactics, alongside the addition of ‘scheduled’ position changes (point 2) to limit the changes to 3 minutes 55 seconds – which were previously somewhat unavoidable in order to catch your opponent off guard. If this is out of the question, we need to think outside the box.
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
sora02 |
39h agoPoint 2 really is the ideal feature.
Changes are programmed for every news update, bringing the game back to being dynamic and interactive.
It has ONLY advantages and absolutely no disadvantages.
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
hazard14 |
23h agoPerso rien de choquant avec ce nouveau mdm
3 IE perdu avec des xg supérieur c'est dans la logique je trouve.
Ce mdm permet vraiment de relativiser et de se dire pour ma part que jai etait vraiment bête de m'investir autant pour le peu d estime qu'on a de nous .
Alors maintenant on va former et faire plaisir a mes amis lfl en aidant les plus motivé si il en reste....
Skyz |
19h agoAs it stands, the gameplay is a disaster; quite simply, there’s nothing you can do against a player who knows what they’re doing.
3-4-3 vs 3-4-3: attack down the wings whilst leaving 30 in the middle so that the opposition’s attacks go down the centre; and given that the attack takes ages to get going, the opposition has plenty of time to block the centre when you try to attack them in that area.
So, in matches between active players: you set your team up and pray for a fluke goal at 0.02xG, then you sit back and defend.
Zero skill, just pure luck
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Pauul76 |
19h agoIt’s to capture the magic of VF, and apparently to keep a large part of the community happy ^^
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Skyz |
18h ago6 more replies
Demi-cerveau |
2h agoDit Skyz. 39 matchs cette saison. 37 victoires, 2 défaites. Merde, la pièce est truquée !
Skyz |
2h agoYes, do bear in mind the friendly matches and those against AFK players (at least 33 out of 39 matches); when we’re talking about matches between active players, that’s good. 💪🏻
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Demi-cerveau |
2h ago39 matches, including 12 cup matches (6 of which were in the Champions League), 7 league matches and 4 friendlies this season.
There you go, I’ve sorted it out 😘.
I’ll let the friendlies slide – we’ve now gone down to 2 defeats out of 23 competitive matches.
That’s good 👍.
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Skyz |
1h agoYeah, there’s a fair few lads in the bunch who don’t follow the matches; even in the Champions League there were some easy wins in the group stage, but as you need to show off without actually following anything, as usual, that’s fine. 💪🏻
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Radio |
1h agoGuys, please put your egos aside and treat the improvement project for what it is: a project, not a Community thread.
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
sora02 |
1h agoI don’t get this line of reasoning.
Are we allowed to win but still think the current version’s rubbish, or not?
Or is it only those who lose who’re allowed to say they’re not enjoying themselves?
Can we separate results from the enjoyment of playing?
Actually, I can see exactly what Skyz means – in my first match I wanted to try something other than a 3/4/3, but I quickly realised what a daft idea that was, with that passive XG being an absolute nightmare
Yesterday, we both fielded the same line-up because that’s what’s been happening for the last two months on the French server (even though changes to the MDM were announced on the very first day)
And the result was that it came down to whoever had the best team, as managerial value no longer exists
It’s a lovely feeling to be acting more like a prison guard than actually trying to do anything.
But every time, someone comes along and talks about the ‘raw result’ perspective to try and discredit this awful feeling that the current gameplay provides.
At the moment, the two active players are only there to check whether the opposing manager has made any changes. Proactivity no longer exists, and interaction even less so.
But you’re so entrenched in your stance to set yourselves apart from the rest of the community that you become almost caricatures in every post.
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
potardinho |
18h agoEncore un match à la pièce en ie aujourd'hui, dommage qu elle tourne souvent dans le mauvais sens, on perd tout ce qui nous motive depuis plus d un mois..
J espère vraiment revoir le mdm de ce jeu fonctionner ,onn y comprend plus rien .
hazard14 |
18h agoIt’s not our complaints that will prompt a response, but rather our lack of activity on the store – something to think about 😀
This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Nicularo |
2h agoDans votre intérêt je vous conseille plutôt d’exprimer votre frustration sur un autre sujet que celui ci afin que les projets d’améliorations restent clairs et courtois…
Je sais, il est peu probable que le MDJ vous écoute, mais en partant à la dérive comme ça en prend doucement le chemin ici, vous entérinez vos chances d’avoir un retour positif.