Le vrai stéphanois |

20/08/2024

Good evening, as you know there are certain rules to respect now for direct transfers. I come across quite a few transfers that leave me very skeptical about the respect of this rule and about the sanctions. For example, I just came across a transfer: 28 years old MDC 94NG And I take a look. Sold 4 days ago for 12 million, a big gift yes. According to the rules the minimum for this player if I am not mistaken is 27M. We are far from that. So yes we can say that this transfer may have been made at auction, but how can we verify? Such a great player, I can't see him leaving for 12 million. In addition this transfer was carried out by two members of the same cartel, enough to leave me very skeptical. The problem is that this is far from being the only very suspicious transfer I come across, that's why I'm ranting. I am deliberately not displaying the names of the clubs concerned or the player because I do not know if it is allowed. Good evening


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

cedriic99 |

21/08/2024

Hello, Since you indirectly mention my transfer, I can confirm that it was bought at auction and that therefore the transfer complies with the regulations in force. It was visible and accessible to all and as said above, I used 100 stars to re-assign it since it had 99 in potential. Now I have trouble understanding your little sentence about the fact that I bought it from a member of my alliance. By looking at the transfer log you can see quite quickly that he sold similar players at the same prices and again at auction.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
cedriic99 Hello, Étant donné que tu cite indirectement mon transfert, je peux te confirmer qu’il a été acheté aux enchères et que de ce fait le transfert respecte le règ…

Le vrai stéphanois |

21/08/2024

👋. I just hadn't thought about the fact that you are reallocated the 99 in power. So yes it was suspicious a transfer at 12M between two members of the same agreement (especially since I didn't know if it was at auction) Imagine your player who is bought by a member of your agreement at 12M (that's the image I had) it's not regulatory at all. But now I was explained how you proceeded, no problem


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Le vrai stéphanois 👋. Je n'avais juste pas pensé au fait que tu es reattribué les 99 en puissance. Donc oui c'était suspect un transfert a 12M entre deux membres de la même ente…

cedriic99 |

21/08/2024

Indeed yes it may seem suspicious but I think that by searching a little more you could have had some answers (history of the selling club, history of the reassigned players etc.) I find it a little limited to make a subject to ask a question about a potential cheating by saying not to want to cite or accuse this or that club, while giving as much information to identify the players in question. It may not have been your goal but in my opinion it strongly resembles a disguised accusation of cheating.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Arnoldo09 |

21/08/2024

He had potential points for the direct play style, the buyer reallocated it and had to pay 10 euros on top of the 12M


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Le vrai stéphanois |

21/08/2024

Okkk thanks for enlightening me on the subject


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

|

21/08/2024

image


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Arnoldo09 |

21/08/2024

Deleted player In this case, should this one be cancelled?


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Arnoldo09 #joueur?jid=498134 Dans ce cas, faudrait annuler celui là ?

|

21/08/2024

I was just asking myself the question, which is why I put that


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
3 more replies
Arnoldo09 #joueur?jid=498134 Dans ce cas, faudrait annuler celui là ?

Magikcats |

21/08/2024

I think it's the 30m price for this player


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Magikcats Je trouve que c'est le prix 30 m pour ce joueur

Arnoldo09 |

21/08/2024

It was 17M base it was cancelled ^^


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Arnoldo09 C'était 17M de base il a été annulé ^^

Magikcats |

21/08/2024

Ahah ok, I hadn't seen that


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

leakcim58 |

21/08/2024

Administrators have a life, they can't see everything. It's very simple. Otherwise we would have to put about ten of them.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Morten34 |

21/08/2024

This is why a transfer can be cancelled up to 60 days after the transaction.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Misha |

21/08/2024

Every transfer can be reported. Since Morten doesn't have 8 arms and 3 heads, I don't see how he could check every sale in the reports. 😅


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Alex-AJA |

21/08/2024

Wasn't there a button to report them back then?


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Alex-AJA Il y avait pas un bouton pour les signaler à l'époque ?

Dino_ |

21/08/2024

On PC it's still relevant but not on the application


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Dino_ Sur PC c'est toujours d'actualité mais pas sur l'application

Alex-AJA |

21/08/2024

Ah, my bad


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Busy |

21/08/2024

It is also necessary to check that the transfer does not come from auctions.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

|

21/08/2024

How do you see it?


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Tu le vois comment?

Busy |

21/08/2024

We don't, but the admins need to see it. What I mean is, you need to make sure before you cry wolf.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Le vrai stéphanois |

21/08/2024

Well, honestly, yes, in a way 😂. I was basically asking if it was cheating, so it's good that I suspected it was cheating. After now, I was told that it wasn't and why, perfect. I didn't think much about it, I didn't think about reattribution at all


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Magikcats |

21/08/2024

Ah ok*


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message