Hello, I understood that for the new championship formula, inactive people would be ejected from the championship. But from how many days is a club considered inactive?

It's a big problem, inactive clubs take the Brazilian championship, dozens of inactive clubs, it's not normal

Fontenit85: Bonjour j'ai cru comprendre que pour la nouvelle formule de championnat les inactif seraient éjecté des championnat. Mais à partir de combien de jour un club et consider comme inactif ?

I would personally say 1 month (but no official source).

Fut une époque lointaine, les clubs étaient supprimés au bout de deux mois d'inactivité.

dinho31: C un grand probleme les club inactif
Prend le championnat brazilian des dizaines des club inactifs c pas normale

The Brazilian league has only been around for a few seasons; the divisions had to be filled while waiting for managers to sign up.

Sure, but it would have been wiser to create it with fewer divisions at the start. Because afterwards it's a huge empty shell, and admins receive messages like: "hello, I'm in Brazilian d5, and in the 3 divisions in front of me there are only inactive people. Wouldn't it be possible to move me up a bit to a higher division?"

If I were an admin, I would answer: "No, when you signed up, you knew exactly what you were getting into. Na!"

If you were? Go ahead 😁

2 months seems a reasonable time frame.

It may be possible that after a month without connection, the club receives an email to warn that its club has become inactive and that it needs its coach.

I have a member who left vf because he had too much work but he will come back the best is to give it time I would say 6 months of inactivity of the broom, I also had the case of those who passed the bac absent 1 month and a half vf is a game (more than that for me) but we also have a life irl besides the hazards of life, example I go back to the hospital I stay 2 months in the hospital I come back to vf I no longer have a championship it's a bit silly anyway, one more thing to sort out before making the new championships

kiki-sainté: J ai un membre qui a lâché vf car il avait trop de boulot mais il va revenir le mieux est de laisser le temps je dirais 6 mois d inactivité du balais ,j ai eu le cas aussi de ceux qui passait le bac absent 1 mois et demi vf est un jeu (plus que ça pour moi ) mais on a aussi une vie irl à côté les aléas de la vie ,exemple je rentre à l hopital je reste 2mois à l hopital je reviens sur vf j ai plus de championnat c est un peu bêta quand même, encore une chose à réglé avant de fai

After that you are just excluded from the championship, no sanction, nothing. I think that after 1 or 2 months of inactivity, it is logical.

I find a season of inactivity to be very reasonable.

Dino_: Après tu es juste exclus du championnat, pas de sanction rien. Je pense qu'au bout de 1 ou 2 mois d'inactivité, c'est logique.

Yeah 1 full season before being considered inactive, that's not crazy...

So someone who is in hospital for 2 months who is in D1 is forced to do everything again because he ended up hospitalized, no pity guys

Logic

kiki-sainté: Donc quelqu un qui est à l hopital 2 mois qui est en d1 est obligé de tout refaire car il s est retrouver hospitalisé aucune pitié les gars

I think that if he had been in hospital for 2 months, I think he would have been relegated.

We are just talking about excluding from the championship but if we follow the reasoning, someone who has been absent for several months and who comes back with infrastructures more at level 10 for example is also unfair.

Excluded from the championship of course but when you have 6 divisions to redo because you were hospitalized I find that unfair, the more you talk about this new championship the more I no longer find myself in your future vf, where is the time when we played for fun it is clearly no longer the case too many rules kill the rule

kiki-sainté: Exclure certes du championnat mais quand t as 6 divisions à refaire car t as été hospitalisé je trouve ça injuste ,plus vous parlez de ce nouveau championnat plus je ne me retrouve plus dans votre futur vf ,ou elle est l époque où l on jouait pour s amuser la c est clairement plus le cas trop de règle tue la règle

Excuse me, but just because you're hospitalized doesn't mean you stop using your phone. After a certain amount of time, I think it's normal for inactive players to be unsubscribed from championships. And I don't see how playing against active players rather than inactive ones would be a problem for the pleasure of playing. If you enjoy doing it, friendly matches exist.

Fontenit85: Je pense que si ca fait 2 mois qu'il est à hosto je pense qui aurait été relégué

Or deceased...OK I'm leaving...

You make me laugh there, you can be hospitalized without a phone and yes it exists in chemo for example, and then the inactive have been part of vf forever it's not from today, the removed ones are going to change what?? Change is beautiful but it has to be done the first thing is to remove all the inactive before 2024 and already there the cleaning will be done, for example in January 2025 we get rid of nothing and in January 2026 we get rid of everything before January 2025, you want to shake everything up but you will see that you will regret it in a few seasons but it's your choice, everyone is free to have their own opinion

Fontenit85: Je pense que si ca fait 2 mois qu'il est à hosto je pense qui aurait été relégué

If the guy left his A not sure he would be relegated

kiki-sainté: Si le mec a laissé sa A pas sur qubil soit relégué

If he gets a red card or gets injured on the first day of the championship, which would seriously handicap him for the rest of the season.

With ifs we can go far, but it doesn't advance your so-called problem of inactive people which is annoying after 16 years of playing :)

kiki-sainté: Avec des si on peux aller loin ,mais ça avance pas votre sois disant problème des inactifs qui gêne après 16 ans de jeu 🙂

I never said I was for it 😉

kiki-sainté: Vous me faites marrer la ,tu peux être hospitalisé sans téléphone et oui ca existe en chimio par exemple , et puis les inactifs font partie de vf depuis toujours c est pas d aujourd hui ,les enlevés ça va vous changez quoi ??
C est beau le changement mais il faut bien le faire le premier truc c est d enlevé tout les inactif d avant 2024 et déjà la le ménage sera fait ,exemple en janvier 2025 on degage rien et en janvier 2026 on dégage tout avant janvier 2025 ,vous voulez tout chambo

It's relatively rare all the same Kiki, in any case I wouldn't wish it on anyone, and if it happens, I'm convinced that Aymeric will listen to find a solution for the return of the manager in question and that it's 2 months or 6 months for that matter ;)

Or a notification that says attention you have not been connected for so many days please connect at least once before such day 😀

The next season is going to be long...It's going to have even more of a "Groundhog Day" feel to it.

Why not consider as "inactive" from 57 days (1 full season we will say otherwise). • After 25/28 days an email for prevention. • At 57 days and/or 1 full season: The club is out of all competitions, and placed on the list of friendly matches. A warning email. • Between 58 and 110 days: auto sale of players to cover finances. • After 112 days and/or 2 seasons start of demotion of the infra if the finances are in the red. (With limits before the next point) • After 170 days and/or 3 seasons and/or when the club has been reduced by half (infra etc) but that it can have capital to restart, the club is "Cryogenized" for a period to be determined (6 months, 1 year), with terms to be defined (friendly, or total deactivation), with the possibility of reactivating its account within this period but by recovering its nerf account like half on the infra and the workforce sold and maybe even a boost like for the new ones. In parallel, have the possibility of activating a "hibernation" mode (vacation/absence/unavailability) with possible options like "expected return date" or "only play friendlies with N10" or any other setting that would put the club in standby mode or total pause.

A priori it is 60 days