Hello,
In matches, we sometimes have injuries, and if we don't make any changes, we play with 10 players.
Except that if we have an injury at the start of the match and unfortunately we weren't able to attend the match, well we play the match with 10 against 11, which is annoying in big matches.
What I'm proposing is that the game automatically substitutes a player in the same position (or almost in the same position if there are no other players in that position available) who doesn't play if there's an injury. This will surely prevent some teams from losing if they have an injured player in their team during the match.
I don't think this idea has been proposed before, but if it has, I apologise.

I think that the said feature is available to those with VIP membership (who invest real money in game), so I don't see it becoming a regular feature.
But I don't think that playing with a player down has as big of an impact as it has in real life, it obviously depends on a player, but, in theory, I think it's possible to weaken a team with a sub for injured player mostly due to affinity and (possibly negative) impact on playing styles.

Andre Malles: I think that the said feature is available to those with VIP membership (who invest real money in game), so I don't see it becoming a regular feature.
But I don't think that playing with a player down has as big of an impact as it has in real life, it obviously depends on a player, but, in theory, I think it's possible to weaken a team with a sub for injured player mostly due to affinity and (possibly negative) impact on playing styles.

But if we play with only 10 players there's no many chances to win.
Once a player is down, he leaves the match, so we're not 11 but 10.

calou5: Bonjour,
En match parfois on a des blessures, et si on ne fait pas de changement, on joue à 10 joueurs.
Sauf que si on a une blessure en début de match et que malheureusement on a pas pu assister au match, eh bien on joue le match à 10 contre 11, ce qui est embêtant dans des gros matchs.
Ce que je propose c'est que le jeu fasse le remplacement automatiquement avec un joueur du même poste (ou presque du même poste si il y a pas d'autres joueurs du poste disponibles) qui ne joue pas si il y a u...

Do you also want automatic tactical changes in case you lose? 😅

Sorry to use irony, fortunately those who follow their matches is an advantage in some circumstances.

Yes, it's absurd, but this is a MANAGEMENT game,
Play FIFA, I think it's more appropriate.

Taking carrots against afk is already a pain in the arse, so if on top of that there are automatic substitutions, there's no point in following the games...

Rull43: Tu souhaites aussi des changements automatiques tactiques au cas où tu perds? 😅

Désolé d'utiliser l'ironie, heureusement que ceux qui suivent leurs matchs est un avantage dans certaines circonstances.

Well, imagine you can't follow the match because of something serious IRL, and one of your players gets injured, well then you'll be glad there's automatic substitution.

calou5: Bah imagine que tu ne peux pas suivre le match à cause de quelque chose de grave IRL, et qu'un de tes joueurs se blesse, eh bien là tu seras bien content qu'il y ait le remplacement automatique.

I think if something bad happens to you, a virtual game is the least of your worries, isn't it? 😭😂

calou5: Bah imagine que tu ne peux pas suivre le match à cause de quelque chose de grave IRL, et qu'un de tes joueurs se blesse, eh bien là tu seras bien content qu'il y ait le remplacement automatique.

Yes, that's life. We're playing a management game. I don't manage well 😅, but others excel. You have to play another game.

Zeus: Je pense que si il t'arrives quelque chose de grave, un jeu virtuel est le dernier de tes soucis non ? 😭😂

No, but once everything's going well again, you remember the match and go and see an injured player who couldn't be replaced.

Rull43: Oui c'est la vie. On joue à un jeu de gestion. Je gère mal 😅, mais d'autres excellent. Faut jouer à un autre jeu.

In itself, his proposal is reasonable!

Against, because it will give afk an advantage, as MDm often does.

Magikcats: Contre, car ça va avantager les afk comme le MDm le fait souvent.
Et quand avant le début si tu es a 10 le jeu rajoute un joueur automatiquement car tu commences a 11

But I'm talking about during the match

calou5: Mais je parle de pendant le match

You have to be present during your match - it makes sense

calou5: Mais je parle de pendant le match

As I said against during the match. Because the MDm often favours the afk (especially in IE), it's better to leave it like that. After an injury if you're afk it's like a red. How many times have I found myself on 10 vs 11. So on the contrary, the day I injure an opposing player, I'm happy (in the game, of course).

I agree with calou. You're kind, but even without a major problem, following championship matches at 10am 11am noon or even 4pm when you have a real job is impossible. The mdm doesn't give afk any advantage. Then having to play 11 against 10 to win a match... Vive les flans...
So why not pre-set changes in the event of injury, with a 10-minute window during the match to give the weaker players time to take advantage of their opponents' bad luck.

Putneg: Je suis d accord avec calou. Vous êtes gentil, mais même sans problème majeur, suivre les matchs de championnat à 10h 11h midi voir 16h quand tu as un vrai taff c est impossible. Le mdm n avantage pas les afk. Puis avoir besoin de jouer à 11 contre 10 pour win un match... Vive les flans...
Donc pkoi pas pré paramétrer les changements en cas de blessures, avec un laps de temps de 10mn dand le match pour laisser le temps aux faibles de profiter de la malchance adverse.

If you watch my championship match yesterday, you'll understand why I say MDM advantage AFK. A match I must have won 100x when you look at the stats (not counting the XGs). + tactics.

I've always struggled more against AFKs (my last IE proves it! against an afk), than against actives.
And that's the case for a lot of managers here.

Yes, I have a league where 3 managers play matches at 8am while I'm at work, but that's the game. But advantaging afk by making an automatic change in case of injury basically means no need to log on to VF during matches.

Magikcats: si tu regardes mon match de championnat d'hier, tu comprendras pourquoi je dis le MDM avantage les AFK. Match que je dois gagner 100x quand tu regardes les stats (sans compter les XG). + tactique.

J'ai toujours + galéré vs des AFK (mon dernier IE le prouve ! vs un afk), que vs les actifs.
Et c'est le cas pour un grand nombre de managers ici.

Oui j'ai un championnat ou 3 managers font des matchs à 8h, durant que je travail, mais bon, c'est le jeu. Mais avantager les afk en faisant un chan...

All you have to do is stay AFK, in which case you'll easily win your championship.

🤣🤣

Galywat: T'as qu'à rester AFK dans ce cas : tu gagneras facilement ton championnat.

Not sure lol, but why not get better results in IE.

Speaking of ie, we need to make one between us. I feel like beating you!

Not long ago, someone suggested the introduction of notifications, I think.
Instead of an automatic replacement, why not add a notification in the event of injury?

Nims57: Il y a pas longtemps, quelqu'un proposait la mise en place de notification il me semble.
Pourquoi pas, plutôt qu'un remplacement automatique, ajouter une notification en cas de blessure ?

But that already exists.
And it still works (you receive an "Injury" message, and therefore, in theory, the notification).

However, it doesn't work for suspensions (at least not for me).

Suspension you get at the end of the match

If I could also have an automatic response to new topics on the vforum, thank you.

Magpie: Mais ça existe déjà ça.
Et pour le coup, ça fonctionne toujours (tu reçoit un message "Blessure", et donc, la notification, en théorie)

En revanche, pas pour les suspensions, ça ne fonctionne plus (enfin chez moi)

I'll have to check my settings then 😅
I do have notifications but only after the match not at the time of injury personally.

Nims57: Il faut que je revois mes paramètres alors 😅
J'ai effectivement les notifications mais après le match seulement pas au moment de la blessure perso

The injury, you have a message, in PMs.
That said.... not all the time.
It didn't work before. But it was fixed a few seasons ago. If you're injured in a match, you get an "Injury" message.

For suspensions, yes, you get the message at the end of the match, when it's a suspensive yellow card (2nd yellow card of the season). But there's no message for an in-match red card, which I think was the aim of this post.

Magpie: La blessure, tu as un message, dans les MP.
Cela dit.... pas tout le temps.
Avant ça ne marchait plus. Mais ça a été réparé il y'a quelques saisons. Lors d'une blessure en match, tu as un message "Blessure"

Pour les suspensions, oui, tu as le message en fin de match, quand c'est un carton jaune suspensif (2e carton jaune de la saison). Mais pas de message pour un carton rouge en match, ce qui était, je pense, l'objectif recherché dans ce post

I'd even say that the message arrives just before the injury appears in the match summary ... like 2/3min before.

Disregard my message, it's just my notifications that are screwing up, not just VF 🤣
So when I posted I might have thought it was already in place 😅

It seems strange to want to automate everything in a management game. You might as well put your club on autopilot, so you can come back every 2 months to see if you've won any titles.

OMstar83: Ca paraît étrange de vouloir tout automatiser sur un jeu de gestion. Autant mettre en pilotage automatique son club, comme ca, on revient tous les 2 mois, pour savoir si on a gagné des titres.

Il n'y a déjà pas grand chose à faire sur vf... il ne faudrait pas non plus supprimer les quelques actions qui nous restent.

Not a great deal? 1.5 hours a day for results that are a bit bogus ... I think that's already too much.

junior: Pas grand chose ? 1h30 par jour des des résultats un peu bidon ...c'est déjà trop je trouve

For an online management game, it's no big deal to have to manage ONE match. After that, we can talk about the real time of a match, yes, it's probably too long these days.
I was talking about the other actions, which take a total of 2 minutes. That's not much. So if we start automating everything so that we don't have to follow a match any more... because that's kind of the point of the proposal. We should also add the option "adapt to the opponent's attack", "modify the style of play to find the most optimal" or whatever. You could push it. Or choose a 'holiday' mode where the game manages absolutely everything.

OMstar83: Pour un jeu de gestion en ligne, c'est pas grand chose de devoir gérer UN match. Aprés, on peut discuter du temps réel d’un match, oui, c’est surement trop long de nos jours.
Je parlais des autres actions surtout qui prennent en tout et pour tout 2 minutes. C’est léger. Donc si on commence à tout automatiser pour ne plus avoir à suivre un match... parce que c'est un peu ca le but avec la proposition. On devrait aussi ajouter l'option "s'adapter à l'attaque adverse", "modifier le style de jeu ...

It's true that replacing injured players during a match is exciting... It would have to take 2 hours, and you'd have to be able to press lots of little buttons every 2 minutes without being able to blink, otherwise it's no fun in Vf.
It's not necessarily all or nothing. And 2 hours a day is good enough, vf is a mobile game, not a full-time job...

Putneg: C est vrai que remplacer les blessés pendant un match c est passionnant... Faudrait que ça prenne 2h, et qu on puisse appuyer sur plein de petits boutons toute les 2mn sans pouvoir cligner des yeux, sinon c est pas drôle vf.
C est pas forcément tout ou rien. Puis 2h par jour c est bien déjà, vf c est un jeu mobile, pas un emplois à plein temps hein...

I didn't say it was exciting. But it's part of the management and if you're not there, too bad. There are thousands of games that send you notifications for anything and everything, a base being attacked for example. If you can't defend it, too bad.