I asked michbou in the transfer section for some conditions on the rules so that they would apply like on vf, michbou wrote to me to tell me that this had been passed on internally for discussion.
I'm opening 1 topic here, which I hope will be short-lived, and I'd like to ask a few questions so that the game runs smoothly.
I'm posting here the rules for the part of the vfo rules where I have questions;

the rules impose 1prix de vente de départ
1 direct purchase price as well as the auction step
So why do we see derisory bids that don't correspond to the sale price?
1 player who places 1 bid is the minimum selling price and yet the rules in place bypass the basic rule.
1enchere must not be shortened because on vf 1joueur qui part aux enchères ne peut plus être retires des enchères 1 fois pose
How is it that a bid on vfo is not taxed by 1 agent as on vf when 1 player is put up for auction (even if the player is not sold)?
the story of the 20% discounts is equivalent to 1 direct bid and totally unfair for other buyers because not everyone has the same readability on the auctions because on vf auctions of this type do not exist it is for everyone the same
i ask the mdj to close the sales of players on vfo while waiting for the transfer part of vfo to be at the same level as on vf concerning auctions
there are 2weights 2measures concerning vf and vfo auctions and this totally distorts prices
The aim of this is not to criticise or anything else but to have 1 semblance of playable games, which is no longer the case and you only need to look at the number of members complaining at the moment.
in my personal opinion, the transfer part on the vfo should not even exist, it was put in place a very long time ago to compensate 1peux the number of sales on vf when the auctions were too numerous, today this is no longer the case and this part no longer serves any purpose.
thank you for reading

Personally, I think that auctions on the vforum should not exist... We have a list transfer module and a vf auction module. I really don't understand what the point is, apart from not selling when you're not happy with the price. That's also why we have list transfers...

Well, technically there's nothing to stop someone doing this kind of bidding on a discord, for example. Or an old-fashioned forum. As long as you can negotiate transfers directly with the clubs, it's just a way of exploiting that possibility...

I don't see the point of removing this part of the VFo. At the very most, remove the starting price, which should correspond to the sale price. And even then, it's not dramatic in itself.

I agree with ManuM.

Rather than an auction section on the VFO, it would be more interesting to have a "transfers" area where you could put information about players you want to sell and about whom you want to inform potential future buyers (over-trained players, youngsters in training with XP to spare, etc).

It's fair and doesn't invite discussion or interpretation of this or that rule. You just have to accept that some players won't be sold at the price you were hoping for.

For anyone wishing to sell their players at a minimum price, there is the transfer list, which is also sufficient, fair and not open to interpretation. You just have to accept that you will have to pay a fee if you aim too high and the player doesn't sell.