Skyz |

2 months ago

Hello, isn’t there a glitch with that match regarding the last goal?
The last update was at 85’ – how come there are two goals?

Because it’s quite worrying to concede two completely out-of-the-blue goals like that at the end when we were completely dominating.
#match?mid=6950383

It’s bad enough that there are those scripted 20–30-minute spells where you can’t create any chances – they drag on – but then to concede two completely out-of-the-blue goals like that at the end is the last straw 😂


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

aymeric45 |

2 months ago

Hello
No bugs, and no scripts.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Skyz |

2 months ago

Right, thanks 🫡

It’s a bit odd, though, to have six chances in 15 minutes and then nothing for 30 minutes, with the same stats. And this has been spotted by colleagues across several matches.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Skyz D'accord merci 🫡 Quand même étrange d'avoir 6 occasions en 15min puis plus rien pendant 30min avec les memes stats. Et ce, repéré sur plusieurs matchs par les…

Galywat |

2 months ago

Hey, there’s nothing inexplicable about that, especially when possession was fairly even or around 60/40
=> your opponent may well have had the upper hand during that period but had little chance of scoring.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
5 more replies
Galywat Yop, en soit rien d’inexplicable d'autant plus avec des possessions assez proches ou autour de 60/40 => ton adversaire a pu tout à fait avoir l'initiative du j…

Skyz |

2 months ago

Yeah, you’re right, I was incredibly lucky for 15 minutes – I had everything going for me – and then for 30 minutes, nothing at all, and then for another 20 minutes, chances came thick and fast. 🫡


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Skyz Oui tu as raison, j'ai eu énormement de chance pendant 15min j'avais tout et puis ensuite pendant 30 minutes plus rien, et puis ensuite pendant 20min retour de…

Galywat |

2 months ago

It’s just a matter of statistics. MDM is simply a game of probabilities.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Galywat C’est juste statistique. Le MDM est un jeu de probabilités.

Skyz |

2 months ago

These probabilities are pretty predictable, though 😅

image


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Skyz Assez prévisible quand même ces probabilités 😅 Exactement la même chose ici, temps fort pendant 25min et plus rien pendant 40min #match?mid=6946758

Galywat |

2 months ago

Well, if it makes you feel better to believe that, then carry on believing it anyway – even though Aymeric’s explaining the opposite to you.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Galywat Bah écoute si ca te soulage d'y croire, bah continue de le faire quand bien meme aymeric t'explique aussi le contraire.

Ced90 |

2 months ago

It’s true that it works in loads of matches, even when you’re completely dominating… It’s glaringly obvious

You’re crushing the opposition (possession, 2 zones with 2 or 3 midfielders + 2 or 3 forwards, etc.)
You might have six chances in 20 minutes, then nothing for 30 or 40 minutes, as if there were moments of momentum (well, of course there are)

But then again, you’ve got to realise that watching for an hour and a half just for that can be a bit of a drag at times


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Galywat |

2 months ago

Yes, I see exactly what you mean. But statistically, it’s entirely explainable. It’s not a systematic occurrence, mind you.

If I draw an analogy with a coin toss, you can regularly get heads four or five times in a row. That doesn’t mean the coin is rigged.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Skyz |

2 months ago

The carrot isn’t really the point – that sort of thing happens to everyone.
I started this thread to ask Aymeric if there was a ‘ghost goal’ bug, as has been the case recently in several matches, and he replied that there wasn’t.

But those 30-minute gaps in matches are a recurring issue, and there’s definitely something going on – either the game is freezing or it’s down to momentum. It can’t possibly be random when it happens so often – you’ve got a clear run on goal with three attacks, 65 per cent possession, five chances in a row, and then nothing.
Then it comes back, and you’re racking up the chances again after waiting half an hour for things to get going again.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Skyz La carotte en vrai c'est pas le sujet, ça arrive à tout le monde ça. J'ai fait le sujet pour demander à Aymeric si il n'y avait pas un bug de but fantome comme…

Galywat |

2 months ago

Just because you can’t see anything in the commentary box (and I agree it would be good to have more information), that doesn’t mean nothing’s happening: your opponent may have the ball and you’re marking them tightly enough to minimise the chance of conceding a chance or a goal, or perhaps you’ve got the ball yourself but the play is ultimately taking place in an area you don’t dominate – or dominate as much – generating xG but no clear-cut chances.

But if you look at the match exports, or watch the matches in question, you’ll clearly see a change in xG during these lull periods.

Probably only slightly, and so in the situations you describe, it’ll likely be in the opponent’s favour; 35 per cent possession is no small thing – they can easily string together a few consecutive moves over 20–25 minutes (or even longer, depending on their success), given how the mdm works. Attacks which, if you block them, almost always result in ‘nothing’ appearing on the commentary screen.

But this isn’t the MDM freezing up (we’ve seen that before; you can spot it with goals at 0.0 xG, incidentally, quite recently).


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

myforsans |

2 months ago

It is indeed a game of probabilities, but we are unaware of almost all the parameters except for one that has been officially published: a chance has a one in four probability of being converted into a goal (is this still the case, by the way? Not sure!)

It is this lack of knowledge that creates a sense of injustice or frustration.

But who can claim to know the exact parameters resulting from supposed dominance?

Who can claim that 75 per cent possession against 25 per cent, and an attack-to-defence ratio of 3:1, gives you three times the probability of creating a chance?

Who can claim to know whether a 1-point increase in that percentage has a linear, exponential or logarithmic impact?

Who can claim that, given the same percentage of dominance, you’ll have twice as many chances simply because you hold that dominance in two out of three areas?

I think that most of the results we find unfair are simply down to a set of parameters that follow their own logic – a logic that isn’t what we think it is.

Until someone has access to the MDM code, they can only conclude that the results do not conform to THEIR logic, but not to THE logic.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

aymeric45 |

2 months ago

I doubt I ever said that a chance had a one-in-four chance of resulting in a goal, as that is not true.

As for establishing a link between possession and the number of goals scored when attack and defence are on an equal footing, it’s not very complicated given that all the data is freely available.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Ced90 |

2 months ago

Aymeric, I think this was demonstrated a few months ago using the available data

Mind you, we’re talking specifically about OPPORTUNITIES DISPLAYED

The difference lies in the probability: the higher the (displayed) chance’s xG value, the more likely it is to result in a goal (which makes sense).
But otherwise, the conversion rate (displayed chance to goal) was 1 in 4


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Ced90 Aymeric, il me semble que cela a été démontré il y a quelques mois avec les datas à disposition Après attention, on parle bien d'occasions AFFICHEES Ce qui dif…

Galywat |

2 months ago

Not exactly; it had been shown that, broadly speaking, y xG equalled y per cent chance of a goal and y × 3 chance of a chance. Consequently, with xG > 0.25, the 4:1 ratio of chances to goals no longer holds true.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
3 more replies
Ced90 Aymeric, il me semble que cela a été démontré il y a quelques mois avec les datas à disposition Après attention, on parle bien d'occasions AFFICHEES Ce qui dif…

brewen |

2 months ago

The data simply showed that, for every four visual actions (green or blue), there were three ‘chances’ (green display) and one ‘goal’ (blue display) up to xG=0.25.

Nevertheless, events invisible to the naked eye do not alter the conversion rate: 0.01 xG still represents a 1 per cent chance of scoring (blue display), a 3 per cent chance of a chance (green display), and a 96 per cent likelihood of taking no shot (no display).

The difference demonstrated a few months ago was an extension of the xG range from [0–0.25] to [0–0.33], which may have recently reverted to the previous range.

I’m reproducing the full summary here, with the following for each xG value:

  • In green, the probability of seeing a green display (chance)
  • In blue, the probability of seeing a blue display
  • In black, the probability that nothing happens (which causes quite a bit of noise here; we can see that this is the highest probability up to around 0.14xG)
  • In orange, the visual cognitive bias that makes it seem as though there’s a 25 per cent chance of scoring, as the black events aren’t visible (goal/(goal+chance) ratio)
    image

This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
brewen La data a simplement démontrée, que pour 4 actions visuelles (vert ou bleu), on devait observer 3 "occasions" (affichage vert) et 1 "but" (affichage bleu) jusq…

Ced90 |

2 months ago

Yes, exactly 👍🏼

That’s explained better 😁


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

myforsans |

2 months ago

Yet that is what was said at the time of a reform aimed at preventing a flood of goals.
The conversion rate from chance to goal was one in four.
That actually ties in quite well with the statistics I keep.
Out of 100 chances, I usually score between 20 and 30 goals.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

aymeric45 |

2 months ago

It is true that a correlation between the frequencies of these two events has probably been demonstrated, but I doubt there is a cause-and-effect relationship, given that there is none.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

hazard14 |

2 months ago

And here I was thinking that some people had actually got the hang of it.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

Ced90 |

2 months ago

Not you, are you? 😂


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Ced90 Pas toi si? 😂

hazard14 |

2 months ago

Oh no, I’d never be so presumptuous, and that’s clear from my results.
But some people thought they knew it off by heart – apparently not.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
3 more replies

Skyz |

2 months ago

The model is accurate enough to predict xG in 99.9 per cent of matches, at any rate.

Even so, understanding the game isn’t enough to guarantee victory because there’s a large element of chance; you can dominate an opponent for an hour and a half and still get knocked out.

Take my Champions League match as proof: whilst I had the best xG of all participants in the round of 32, there’s no guarantee of success, and others who played matches with very low xG values went through to the next round on a fluke.
That’s why the winner changes every season and why there are sometimes ‘lucky’ winners who you’ll never see make it past the round of 16 again – that’s just how random it is.
I think it’s a bit of a blot on the “competitive” aspect of the game’s top competition.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
Skyz La compréhension est assez bonne pour avoir les xG dans 99,9% des matchs en tout cas. Après même comprendre le jeu n'est pas suffisant pour se garantir la vict…

hazard14 |

2 months ago

It’s a way of saying that the MDM is ultimately random.
We mustn’t forget the team statistics, which, in my view, play a major part in the equation.
This is just my opinion, but the seasons seem to prove me right – or at least I see less of certain teams’ dominance, or less of an over-dominance of others’ xG.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message
hazard14 Cest une façon de dire que le mdm est aléatoire au final . Faut pas oublier les stats équipes qui pour moi rentre fortement en compte dans l adittion . Ce n'es…

Skyz |

2 months ago

It depends on the players and their understanding of the MDM; some may have a better team than others but will still produce very average xG figures against opponents who know the system better than they do.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message

OMstar83 |

2 months ago

No bug. The answer has been given, so the thread should be closed, as normal. There are already plenty of threads about the MDM elsewhere.


This message has been translated. (FR) Original message