Is it chance or is it the way the game is set up?
At the moment I have 10 midfielders out of 12 on yellow cards!
On the other hand, I have 0 strikers out of 7 who are cautioned.
I know that goalkeepers never get yellow cards, but what about the other positions?
Have you noticed that the midfielders are more exposed than the others to carding?
I wanted to check whether it's the same at other clubs, but unfortunately when you look at another club's figures you can't see which players have been cautioned (and I'm not sure why).

My midfielders
image](https://i.imgur.com/CQlTbf8.jpeg)
My forwards

image](https://i.imgur.com/8mhpF2w.png)
your observation is correct

Same thing but more defenders ...
Deja eu un rouge sur un MD
And a DF red since the start of the season

Personally, several of us have noticed that when learning a new position, it gives the strikers a hard time and often leads to injury, so this is not a statement but simply a fact from matches.
Now 1 question arises as we're talking about it.
if we can already see that the mdj is scraping the youngsters back and forth to lower the ng, wouldn't it be wiser to avoid losing precious xp?
for the blind to choose 1peux less strong but more complete on the posts
for vf to choose several posts and lose 1peux of talent
to optimize to the max and limit the breakage on the ng
I think it's a dig

H. Bourdillat original atd yesterday he finished m asg so I put him moc 10 minutes after red card for him
At the moment I've got 3 red cards, two of which are among my young players. To that I add a dfc from my A team and an injured dfc from my A team, and I'm playing with a dfc who hasn't finished his training.
Fortunately tomorrow I'll have 3 players out of 4 back, including my 2 starting dfc, because it's going to be difficult to manage the defence if he gets injured or sent off I'll be playing without a dfc, no choice.

The subject is getting a bit out of hand!
It's all over the place: it's not a question of training, injuries or NGs that we're talking about here.

The only question is: do your midfielders get carded more often than your players (excluding goalkeepers) in other positions, and in particular my strikers, who never get carded?

Strikers get very few cards, if any at all
The defenders and especially the midfielders are the most exposed; I'd even go so far as to say that the right-back line is the most exposed.

Where I come from, I think defenders take more reds than midfielders. The strikers are actually relatively spared, and more likely to take a straight red than a yellow (it seems to me).

In my defence 2 yellows and a red (last night)
In the middle 5 yellows

2 defenders and 3 defensive midfielders on yellow cards at the moment.

4 def and 4 midfields at my place... I think they're pretty evenly spread, in fact

Likewise, I don't remember seeing a striker get carded, or only if the guy in front of him is really aggressive, and often it's the asc who tends to get the card.

Personally, I have two defenders and 4 midfielders with one card. But for a striker it's true that it's extremely rare, I don't remember it. I also have the feeling that it's mainly the midfielders who get carded, but the defenders also get carded, but a bit less I think.

It's supposed to be proportional, we play with less strikers than midfielders or defenders, so maybe less cards for the strikers.

So my hunch seems to be right: a striker who scores is about as rare as a defender who scores!

Now we're going to get more to the strikers and no less to the others. 🤣
Well done for waking the beast 😘

Rull43: Maintenant on va en avoir en plus aux attaquants et pas moins aux autres. 🤣
Bravo d'avoir réveillé la bête 😘

What's more, the gac don't take any.
I'm just saying. 😂

I may have a solution thanks to a colleague of mine
@Eden hzrd !

Si on joue avec 5 attaquants, il y aurait moins de cartons au milieu ou en défense selon la ou l'joue sans joueurs 😃