Hi
I won the bid for this player but the transfer is cancelled
An explanation please

The player had been bought for 100k and then put up for auction.
So the transfers were cancelled

The explanation is that the club that sold him to you had just bought him for 0.1 M, which is far too low a price according to the regulations. That's why the transfer was cancelled.

Keep the patrol happy.

Can I ask if an update of the prices of the paintings is planned, because even if some youngsters are selling at a high price these days, the prices seem to me to be falling. We always look at the boards with our agreements to be within the rules and in some cases at the minimum price, we can end up paying more than what we can find on VF.

It's true that prices in general have fallen since Morten updated the table.
But I don't think the market has fallen by 50%

I trust you for the calculations, but it would be nice an update if possible. Because still bcp listen hehe and follow the table. 😀

It's true that this table is a good starting point, especially for people like me who don't follow the market one iota. After that, it's a lot of work, but it would be nice to be able to update it every season, maybe, or every other season, I don't know. All in all, it's a lot of work, but it also saves the admins 50 mp a day asking for the right price for this or that player, for fear of having the transfer cancelled. If you want to do everything to the max (thanks to people who abuse everything), you can, but you're obliged to follow what you put in place.

OMstar83: Il est vrai que ce tableau est une bonne base de départ, surtout pour les gens comme moi qui ne suivent pas d'un iota le marché. Après, c'est du travail mais il serait bien de pouvoir le mettre à jour chaque saison peut-être ou toutes les deux saisons, je n'en sais rien. Et puis, l'un dans l'autre, ça fait du taff mais ça évite aussi les 50 mp par jour aux admins pour demander un prix correct pour tel ou tel joueur, de peur de se faire annuler le transfert. Si on veut tout boucler au max

if the mdj had wanted this table it would have done it like in the past
this board has nothing to do with the rules of the game, it is just there to facilitate 1 work of admins but in no way it facilitates the game play of players and even scares them away.
I know people won't like me saying this but it's 1 fact

redbull77: si le mdj avait voulu de ce tableaux la il l aurrait fait comme par le passe
ce tableaux n a rien a faire dans le reglement du jeux , il est juste la pour faciliter 1 travail des admins mais en aucun cas il ne facilite le game play des joueurs et les fais fuir meme ..
Je sais que ca va pas plaire que je le dise mais c est 1fait

to go even further in my demarche, when a45 had put 1 price to these players there in the past many complained and the price of the players disappeared, here it is exactly the same except that it was done manually by 1 or more admins.
there is a game made by A45 and 1GAME created by the admins, that's what's wrong

Instead of talking without knowing, I invite you to read this topic and the message posted by Aymeric on page 5: #forum?topic=165322

Morten34: Au lieu de parler sans savoir, je t’invite à lire ce topic et le message posté par Aymeric en page 5: #forum?topic=165322

mais tkt morten j'ai bien lu le tout et je n'étais pas du tout d'accord mais je n'ai rien dit à cette moment
but tyson was blocked for purchases from the store that were later resold ....
don't mix everything up morten please
your table doesn't concern the blind because there are rules in place for that by A45
you see, I know a lot more than you think, and if I want to say that this board is driving players away from the game, that's my right, and I'm not going to say it whether you like it or not
bonne journee

And whether you like it or not, I'm also entitled to say that you're way off the mark when you write "there's the game made by A45 and 1GAME next to it created by the admins, that's what's being criticised".
I just don't think you've read Aymeric's answer properly.

Morten34: Et que cela te plaise ou pas, je suis aussi en droit de dire que tu es à côté de la plaque quand tu écris "il y a le jeux fait par A45 et 1JEUX a cote cree par les admins c est cela qui est repproche principalement".
Je pense justement que tu n'as pas bien lu la réponse d'Aymeric.

if I've read correctly, you created 1 game in the game with your board and it wasn't up to you to do it at the time
It's not 1 repproach that you've made but 1 mistake and you have to admit to your mistakes too, as the long list in the transfer log attests.
A chaque fois que j'entends des membres sur discord qui vendent des joueurs , ils disent il fait chier ce tableau on nous impose des prix ...
1membre qui forme et qui resale ne vendra forcement pas au meme prix
1memembre qui fait sa nation acheteza tj plus cher
ext ext
now continue in this direction and soon on the 250 pages of the newspaper you will only have purchases from inactive clubs
do you know that most of the agreements are selling players to each other now because of this table?
I doubt that was A45's original aim
i've finished on this topic and will leave you the last word as usual I love you anyway morten

What you shouldn't read, frankly... 😆 And it makes more mistakes than I do 😅

And I repeat that we drew up these tables at Aymeric's express request, it was in no way a personal initiative. And once the work was done, these tables were validated internally by Aymeric himself before being integrated into the rules. I hope you understand this time.

Morten34: Et je répète que nous avons fait ces tableaux à la demande express d'Aymeric, ce n'est en aucun cas une initiative personnelle. Et une fois le travail effectué, ces tableaux ont été validés en interne par Aymeric himself avant d'être intégrés dans le règlement. J'espère que tu auras compris cette fois-ci.

yes and the error has been there since the creation on this table there
et oui vous avez fait et non A45 c'est bien ce qui est repproche ....
aymeric a su le faire sur le store, c'était pas complique de trouver 1similitude sur le jeu et non aux admins de le faire.
t'as même pas idée de comment c'est chiant si tu veux vendre 1joueur a aller chaque fois sur ces foutus tab pour en voir les prix de peur de te faire annuler les transferts ( le crédit au moins vous ne donnez pas les amendes quand c'est annule )
now to make you understand what I'm saying.
A45 has made his changes with the blind and it simply doesn't match your table and you can't align yourself with the blind for the simple reason that the blind is based on the level of the club.
now I hope that you too have understood that for 8 months and this table the transfer log has been in ghost mode
that the agreements for not that the money goes out and that the players leave sell the players between them and that creates even more the pit in the market of the transfers it is even more 1 pit that becomes 1abysse there.
i'm talking to the player here, not the admin
pose simplement a la place d'un joueur qui est obligée a chaque fois de se faire chier a aller sur le forum, trouve le bon tab pour vendre 1joueur, admet au moins que c'est 1contrainse

And I repeat, because you must not have read Aymeric's speech, it was following a complaint that the regulator imposed these tables. That's it, we're not going to talk about it for hours. That's the way it is, whether we like it or not.

There are auctions to sell. No fixed price.

Morten34: Et je répète parce que tu n'as pas du lire l'intervention d'Aymeric, c'est suite à une plainte que le régulateur a imposé de faire ces tableaux. Voilà, on ne va pas en parler pendant des heures. C'est comme ça et c'est tout, que ça nous plaise ou pas.

of course I've read it, but it's precisely because of the appreciation of a morten admin that there is this current constraint - that's what I'm getting at
A45 has made changes to the store
you can no longer sell 1 player for 3 seasons without being taxed 100% ON the capital gain
1membre qui va acheter votre joueur pendant ses3saisons il serra aussi taxe dessus ( encore 1aberration )
so we, the members of the game, are being singled out for this additional assessment, which concerned the store and not the auction of the game
Now that A45 has rectified the problem with the blind, I no longer see the need for a table for the game itself.
THE REGULATOR has stuck his nose in because these were purchases on the store and not on the game, before you didn't have tables on the game and it worked very well without 1 regulator saying anything.

leakcim58: Il y a les enchères pour vendre. Pas de prix imposer.

#transferts?log
you can see how the market works
the store is currently 20% OF SALES of the game (for decent players) or close to it, so the problem comes from elsewhere

leakcim58: Il y a les enchères pour vendre. Pas de prix imposer.

let's talk 2sec about auctions if you don't mind
above I was talking about players and money staying in the agreements and I'm going to explain to you why
you are in 1 good agreement with good clubs you are going to put 1 player up for auction at 0sur x heures
when 1club outside your agreement is going to bid on your player you have 1mec from your agreement who is going to raise the price and so on, never too high because prices are not high at the moment and even if the club that wanted the player drops out, well the player and the money stay in the agreement
that's the famous abyss that's created and this board has a lot to do with it because you could get round this problem with direct sales
when I go to auctions I always look at the clubs that are bidding on the player and the result is always the same.

The regulator's request concerns list transfers.
And it's not up to an admin to decide, since it was requested and approved by Aymeric.
What else can I say? Personally, I'm going to stop here and leave you with your certainties.
Have a nice day!

Drezzo35: Ce qu'il faut pas lire franchement... 😆 Et en plus, ça fait plus de fautes à la ligne que moi 😅

Ton ex pour le gars qui veut se faire une équipe d'une seule nation , il sera dans les cordes du tableau si tu avais tout bien lu et regarder 😉 y a le prix on va dire normal mais tu peux aussi acheter plus cher comme moins cher , le tableau l autorise , juste il encadre pour ne pas que ça parte dans l abus , ni plus ni moins

It's so unreadable and incomprehensible that you can't understand anything 🤣🤣
I don't even make the effort to read anymore knowing the character 😅😀